| YEAR | Distinguished Coach | Distinguished Male Athlete | Distinguished Female Athlete |
| 2012 | Wally Kincaid (Baseball) | Ron Yary (Football) | Barbara Reinalda (Softball) |
| 2013 | Gene Martin (Track/Administration) | Marcelo Balboa (Soccer) | Traci Dahl (Volleyball) |
| 2014 | Nancy Kelly (Softball) | Antonio McKee (Wrestling) | Shelley (Bowcutt) Hall (Basketball) |
| 2015 | Rhea Black (Tennis) | Bob Vaughn (Baseball) | Vernecia Smith (Track & Field) |
| 2016 | Jack Bogdanovich (Basketball) | Danny Garcia (Water Polo/Swimming) | Teresa Velasquez-Ortega (Volleyball) |
| 2017 | Jeff Smith (Wrestling) | Lorenzo Romar (Basketball) | April Brown (Track & Field) |
| 2018 | Bob Foerster (Basketball) | Willie Joseph (Basketball) | Samie (Garcia) Zuidema (Softball) |